Storm After the Storm: Pier Politics Rattle Fort Myers Beach
Lee County Dismisses Local Input, Funding For Robust FMB Pier Design Despite Governor's Strong Tourism Numbers
By Richard Luthmann
In Hurricane Ian’s aftermath, the Fort Myers Beach community has faced monumental challenges in rebuilding and restoring what was lost to nature's wrath. The iconic Fort Myers Beach Pier is among the most symbolic and economically vital structures affected. This landmark, more than just a structure, represents the spirit, resilience, and community of Fort Myers Beach, serving as a hub for locals and a major draw for tourists.
Recognizing the Pier's integral role in the community's identity and the local economy, residents, business owners, and local organizations have rallied together with a common purpose: to propose a comprehensive rebuild of the FMB Pier that not only restores its former glory but also enhances its appeal and functionality. This collective vision aims to transform the pier into a state-of-the-art facility that could better serve the community's needs and act as a beacon for visitors, thus providing a much-needed boost to the local economy post-disaster.
However, realizing this vision requires collaboration, transparency, and support from Lee County officials. In particular, the community has directed its requests and inquiries to Commissioner Ray Sandelli, seeking his engagement and leadership in the project.
Governor DeSantis’s office has lauded Florida’s strong tourism numbers. They make the economic case for a world-class pier as a driver for economic activity and local government revenue. FMB residents and stakeholders are calling for detailed financial information and plans from Lee County, hoping to understand how they can contribute meaningfully to the reconstruction efforts. The stakeholders stand ready to transform the FMB Pier into a landmark that honors the past while looking confidently toward the future. To move forward effectively, they require Lee County officials' support, engagement, and transparency to realize this shared vision.
Yet, despite their eagerness and willingness to support, the community is at a standstill, awaiting crucial information and guidance from county officials. Lee County's lack of response and detailed planning, particularly the silence from Commissioner Sandelli and Lee County's press office, has left stakeholders in limbo, unsure of how to proceed or contribute effectively.
Commissioner Ray Sandelli's Background
Commissioner Ray Sandelli is a prominent figure within Lee County's political landscape, representing District 3. Before his venture into politics, Sandelli enjoyed a successful career in commercial real estate, holding senior positions at CBRE, one of the world's largest real estate services firms. His extensive background in real estate provided him with valuable insights into property development, management, and investment, skills that are undoubtedly beneficial in his role as a county commissioner.
Beyond his professional achievements, Sandelli has a distinguished record of public service, particularly in the military. Before his business career, he served as a naval aviator and was part of the Blue Angels, the United States Navy's flight demonstration squadron renowned for its precision and grace in aerial maneuvers. This experience instilled in him a strong sense of discipline, leadership, and commitment to excellence.
Sandelli's transition into public service continued with his appointment by Governor Ron DeSantis in 2019, after which he was elected in 2020. His tenure as a commissioner has been marked by a commitment to economic development, infrastructure improvement, and community service. He has been involved in various educational, charitable, and civic organizations, showcasing his dedication to the community and its development.
Despite his impressive resume and history of service, Sandelli's approach to the FMB Pier reconstruction project has raised questions and concerns among local residents and stakeholders. They seek his leadership and transparency in the rebuilding process. The community looks to Sandelli's background in real estate and public service as a foundation for guiding the pier's reconstruction in a way that respects the community's needs and aspirations.
Stakeholder Initiatives and Challenges
The aftermath of Hurricane Ian has catalyzed a strong community response, with stakeholders eager to contribute to a visionary project for the pier's reconstruction. Business owners, community groups, and residents have unified under the shared goal of rebuilding and enhancing the pier to symbolize resilience and beacon for future prosperity. Among the key figures in these efforts are Town Council Member Karen Woodson and members of the dedicated Let's Go FMB! Pier Committee, particularly Alan Shanosky.
As a Town Council Member, Karen Woodson has been instrumental in voicing the community's aspirations and concerns, striving to ensure that the reconstruction process aligns with the broader interests and vision of FMB residents. Her involvement signifies the local government's commitment to the project and underscores the importance of aligning municipal strategies with community expectations.
Meanwhile, Alan Shanosky and the Let's Go FMB! Pier Committee exemplifies grassroots engagement and proactive research. Over the past year and a half, Shanosky has dedicated considerable time and effort to understanding the intricacies of pier reconstruction. His comprehensive research has taken him across Florida and the Eastern seaboard, where he has visited various piers to gather insights and best practices that could inform the FMB Piers rebuild. He presented his findings to the FMB Town Council last September. This hands-on approach underlines the committee's commitment to ensuring the new pier reflects the community's needs and the latest design and functionality.
Despite these concerted efforts and the community's willingness to support the pier project financially and through direct involvement, progress has been stymied by a significant lack of communication and detail from Lee County officials. The absence of concrete plans, timelines, and cost estimates has posed a major barrier to advancing the project.
“I would like to know how much money [Lee County] needs to rebuild a forward-looking pier. Give us a chance to fundraise and finance,” said a local FMB community leader who wishes to remain unnamed.
Stakeholders are ready to mobilize resources, plan fundraising activities, and engage in collaborative planning, but the absence of crucial information from county representatives has left them in limbo.
The disconnection between the community's preparedness and the county's reticence has led to growing stakeholder frustration. Despite their readiness and eagerness to contribute to the pier's reconstruction, they cannot proceed with meaningful planning or fundraising initiatives if Lee County officials do not provide information. The situation calls for bridging this gap with increased transparency, communication, and collaboration.
Communication and Information Attempts By Local News Outlet
Sun Bay Paper (www.sunbaypaper.com) is a legacy media outlet covering Fort Myers Beach and the surrounding area. The publication is listed with the University of Florida’s journalism archive at the George A. Smathers Libraries.
First Email - March 5, 2024
Sun Bay Paper contacted Commissioner Sandelli and the Lee County Press Office seeking background, transparency, and community involvement details on the FMB Pier rebuild:
Subject: Comment on Fort Myers Beach Pier Rebuild
Date: 03-05-2024 04:13 PM
From: Sun Bay Paper <production@sunbaypaper.com>
To: dist3@leegov.com
Dear Commissioner Sandelli or his Press Agent,
I am the Editor in Chief of the Sun Bay Paper. I have a couple of questions.
Does the Commissioner have any comment about the Fort Myers Beach Pier Rebuild?
Specifically, why does he not support a larger, longer, more modernized pier to accommodate visitors and tourists and stimulate economic activity?
Can Mr. Sandelli give a few examples from his business career at CBRE where investments weren't forward-looking or economic activity-generating, but the deals were still made? What were the business considerations in play?
What have been the highlights of the Commissioner's tenure? (Ian is an obvious low-light for everyone).
What does the Commissioner think about some of the plans for a larger, more robust pier, which would generate economic activity, promote tourism, and elevate Fort Myers Beach as a top tourist destination?
Thanks in advance.
Regards,
Richard Luthmann
Editor-in-Chief
Sun Bay Paper
Second Email - March 8, 2024
Sun Bay Paper sent a second request to Commissioner Sandelli and Lee County Press Officer Betsy Clayton. Tourism Committee Chairman and Commissioner Cecil Pendergrass was also copied.
Subject: Fwd: Comment on Fort Myers Beach Pier Rebuild
Date: 03-08-2024 09:45 AM
From: Sun Bay Paper <production@sunbaypaper.com>
To: BClayton@leegov.com, Dist3 <dist3@leegov.com>
Cc: "Cecil Pendergrass Lee County Board of County Commissioners, District 2" <dist2@leegov.com>
Ms. Clayton,
Does Commissioner Sandelli have any response or statement about the questions below?
Some are concerned that Fort Myers Beach residents and businesses will have no say in the Pier Rebuild. Beach Talk Radio published that a source close to the commissioners said that the community was 'late to the game.' Does Commissioner Sandelli believe that? Particularly after it was on record at the county subcommittee admitted last month that Lee County 'was behind' on the pier project.
Will Fort Myers Beach residents have a chance to hear what the price tag will be for a robust pier? If community groups can make up the shortfall, will they have an opportunity to secure the funds?
Where does the tourism committee, with its surplus, stand?
Does Lee County disagree with Governor DeSantis' tourism numbers? If so, what numbers does Lee County rely upon?
I don't go to press until next week, so I don't need answers immediately.
Thank you.
Regards,
Richard Luthmann
Editor-in-Chief
Sun Bay Paper
As of press time, these communications remain unanswered.
Florida's Tourism Surge and the Case for a Robust Pier Rebuild
Governor Ron DeSantis' recent announcement regarding Florida's tourism statistics presents a compelling argument for the substantial reconstruction of the Fort Myers Beach Pier. Even the New York Times concedes that Florida is a tourism “juggernaut.”
According to the Governor's office, a recent study commissioned by VISIT FLORIDA shows that with the record-breaking number of visitors in 2022, travelers spent a record $124.9 billion, outpacing 2021 by nearly $20 billion. For every dollar spent by the 137.4 million visitors in 2022, 97 cents were retained in the Florida economy. On average, visitors contribute $333 million daily to Florida’s economy.
“Whether for business or vacation, people continue to visit Florida and support Florida businesses because of our commitment to keeping the economy open and allowing businesses to thrive without arbitrary government restrictions,” said Governor Ron DeSantis. “Florida is the best state in the nation to bring your business and vacation with your families.”
These remarkable figures underline tourism's significant role in Florida's economy and highlight the vast potential for further growth and development. The Fort Myers Beach area, with its beautiful beaches, vibrant community, and cultural attractions, constitutes a crucial part of this tourism ecosystem.
Historically, the pier is a central feature of Fort Myers Beach and has been a significant draw for both locals and visitors, contributing to the area's appeal and economic prosperity. Aside from the beaches, the FMB Pier is the most visited tourist attraction in Lee County.
The record-breaking tourism numbers reported by Governor DeSantis make a compelling case for a robust rebuild of the Fort Myers Beach Pier. Reconstructing the pier is a critical step in the area's recovery from Hurricane Ian and a strategic investment in the future of Florida's tourism industry. A new, world-class pier could enhance the visitor experience, attract more tourists, and symbolize resilience and renewal for the community.
Moreover, the surge in tourism highlights the need for infrastructure that can accommodate the growing number of visitors while providing them with memorable experiences. A state-of-the-art pier could offer various attractions, amenities, and services, making Fort Myers Beach an even more attractive destination and contributing to increased economic activity.
“We collect more in county revenue in a few hours on Fort Myers Beach during the season than Alva or Lehigh Acres does the entire year,” said a local business owner who did not wish to be named. “I’m at a loss as to where the [Lee County Tourism] money goes if not to projects like the FMB Pier.”
In light of these facts, the argument for investing in a comprehensive rebuild of the Fort Myers Beach Pier is stronger than ever. The time is ripe for action, with the state's tourism numbers offering a robust foundation for the case for an ambitious pier rebuild that aligns with Florida's bright tourism future.
A Call for Transparency and Action
The reconstruction of the FMB Pier is more than a construction project; it's a pivotal moment for community revitalization and tourism revival post-Hurricane Ian. The community's request is straightforward yet imperative: transparency, detailed plans, and active involvement in the reconstruction process. A comprehensive understanding of the project's scope, budget, and timeline is crucial for stakeholders to contribute effectively.
This call to action extends beyond mere reconstruction; it is a plea for a collaborative approach that respects and incorporates the community's input and vision. The residents and local organizations are more than willing to partner with Lee County, bringing resources, ideas, and a shared commitment to the table. They recognize that the pier symbolizes the community's spirit and a linchpin in the local economy, particularly in light of Florida's burgeoning tourism, as underscored by Governor DeSantis' impressive tourism figures.
However, Lee County's current lack of engagement stymies this potential partnership and progress. The absence of clear communication and shared planning delays the project and dampens the community's morale and trust in local governance.
Therefore, this is a call for transparency and action from Commissioner Sandelli and Lee County officials. It is an appeal to recognize the FMB Pier's importance as a physical entity, a beacon of community strength, and a catalyst for economic recovery. The FMB community stands ready to turn Hurricane Ian's tragedy into a beacon of growth, unity, and prosperity. Yet, they need their elected officials' support, collaboration, and leadership to achieve this.
Lee County must respond now, open the doors to collaboration, and work with the community. They can rebuild a pier and a brighter, stronger future for Fort Myers Beach.